together, we can move philadelphia beyond fossilized democracy

Mariner East 2

The Mariner East 2 is a pipeline slated to travel east from Washington County along the Ohio border into Delaware County in Southeastern PA, through 17 counties. The company building it is Sunoco Logistics.

Image credit: landscapes2.org
Image credit: landscapes2.org

Public concerns about this pipeline

  • Crosses 4 environmental justice areas [reference?]
  • DEP found deficiencies in company’s application forcing it to resubmit documents and delaying construction. Deficiencies include a lack of storm water management; plans for pump stations; unidentified exceptional wetlands; lack of construction detail for water crossings; no mention of nearby drinking water wells, and more.
  • Eminent Domain – In July, 2016 the PA state appeals court ruled that since Sunoco a public utility, it can use eminent domain to gain access to private property, even  homes and farmland. And Sunoco boasts about it here: “Sunoco argues that their use of eminent domain is justified because Mariner East II will provide a public benefit by providing extra propane to residents in offload points throughout the state.” (8/31/16. DeSmog Blog).
  • Highly volatile liquids are classified as liquids by the federal government. Because of this, operators don’t need to develop area-specific response plans for leaks. FracTracker made interactive blast radius map [reference?]. It shows that just in Chester County, there are 31,632 residents at risk. The US Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) show that Sunoco has the worst safety record of 1,518 active pipeline operators that report their operating data to PHMSA. (8/31/16, Desmog Blog)
  • Minimum of 47 mainline valve stations and 18 pumping stations required. Some require new land disturbances. Would cross 581 wetlands, 1,227 streams.
  • How many farming & tourism jobs lost when the pipeline is built? Any other businesses hurt?

Public Resistance

This pipeline has generated an unprecedented 29,000 public comments to DEP, most against it’s construction. The Sierra Club has sent out action alerts and are working with local groups in Chester County. The Delaware Riverkeeper Network filed a petition to intervene in 2014; have taken other legal actions; have testified against this pipeline at DRBC hearing on 10 Nov 2015; have sent action alerts to their members; organized “FERC Doesn’t Work” event at National Press Club. The Clean Air Council has legally fought Sunoco’s status as public utility; in 2014 sponsored Chester County Community Coalition; in 2016 developed a public website, see cleanair.org/dirty-energy/pipelines. Grassroots group Resist Sunoco PA supporting efforts in several counties.

Sunoco Logistics has acquired rights of way on more than 2,600 tracts, the vast majority of those being negotiated easements that did not involve any court action.

  • Washington County
  • Allegheny County
  • Westmoreland County – 270 properties crossed
  • Indiana County
  • Cambria County
  • Blair County
  • Huntingdon County – In March 2016, the Gerhart family of Huntingdon County tried direct action to stop Sunoco Logistics from cutting trees on their land; this is before permits were even obtained for pipeline construction. The court costs were supported by Energy Justice Network.  The family is working with Juniata Watershed’s People Before Pipelines and has set up Camp White Pine for supporters.
  • Juniata County – Juniata Watershed People Before Pipelines (997 people)
  • Perry County
  • Cumberland County – R. Scott & Pamela Martin and Harvey & Anna Nickey of Cumberland County are landowners fighting Sunoco Logistics use of eminent domain to take over their land. (12/29/16, Penn Live)
  • Dauphin County
  • York County
  • Lebanon County – Lebanon County‘s GoFundMe page
  • Lancaster County – Affects 6.5 miles in northern Lancaster County.
  • Berks County – Impacts 221 acres, per this.

    Image credit: readingeagle.com
    Image credit: readingeagle.com
  • Chester County – Affects 23.6 miles with impacts on 184 acres.

    image credit: philly.com
    image credit: philly.com
  • Delaware County – Affects 11.4 miles with impacts on 83 acres. Delaware County municipalities Middletown, Swarthmore, Thornbury, Westtown, Rose Valley and the Rose Tree Media School District have all passed resolutions expressing grave concern about plans for this pipeline. Media Borough Council sent a letter of support for the proclamation adopted by their neighbors in Middletown. (12/19/16, DelCoTimes) (www.eastbootroad.com)The most active group seems to be the Middletown Coalition for Community Safety (MCCS).Patricia Yevins (and 3 neighbors) whose 50-acre farm near West Middletown will be bisected by the pipeline after she lost her eminent-domain case. Sunoco demanded the right to come back within three years and build an adjoining pipeline without additional compensation.  Awaiting a decision by a mediator to determine how much compensation Sunoco must pay to cross their land, though the company has already cleared the rights of way and dug the trench.
  • New Castle County, DE
%d bloggers like this: